长篇影评
1 ) 完全不解梗的
每一集都是设一个梗,雷声大雨点小的,到下一集梗就莫名其妙的消失了。耿直老家亲戚来让耿直找工作,闹得正慌,两个人一副没工作不罢休的样子,外加耿直妈一口一句不给找好工作就是找了媳妇没了娘的架势。下一集跟没这回事似的,风平浪静,舒曼一句:“找不到工作,回去了呗!”就没了。要不要这么虎头蛇尾啊?
耿直被怀疑外遇,舒曼哭了一晚上,上一集耿直正在头疼,下一集就啥事没有了两口子倍儿和谐。拜托,你设个梗,好歹也给解了吧?淡化得也太突然了吧?给我个逻辑理由让他俩和好很难吗?!现实生活里你试试跟别的女人搂搂抱抱然后你啥也不做你老婆会原谅你?你以为你是一集一故事那种情景剧啊?情景剧也不能这么不靠谱啊!
这剧全靠对白撑起,其他真没什么有意思的。两主角横看竖看,不如楚主任一家和谐,不如菲菲可爱。尤其是舒曼,结了婚,明知季诚对她有意,还不放过人家。表面上好像自己一副解救世人不能对不起人家人家不幸福她内疚的样子,其实就是怕医院的人说是她害了季诚。等季诚回国,她又装好人拉拢季诚和菲菲,其实就是想在耿直面前显摆自己有多受欢迎,季诚多忘不了她。如果她真心想拉拢人家,那菲菲给喜糖的时候,她又干嘛摆出一副不爽的样子?有资格不爽吗她?自己一不开心就去找季诚吐苦水,不见她跟菲菲吐?爽了就在菲菲面前显摆。风骚得要死不要脸的那个是她自己才对。真想不明白这种男人一味迁就女人可怜巴巴,女人结了婚还死发骚不要脸的夫妻有什么好值得拿出来拍的。丢人。
胡军的角色也许很多人觉得讨喜,也想找个这样的老公。但他真让人气啊,一味的迁就不是对对方好,搞不好就是害了对方。如果他能在适时的时候拿出男人的样子,他老婆也不会放肆成这样。对老婆好是值得赞许,但一味迁就真要不得,又一个爱之适足害之的经典范例。
2 ) 不禁让人回忆过去半个世纪祖辈、父辈的命运、经历和婚姻
I rarely watch soap operas, but after taking a glance on TV last week, I took the whole Saturday to watch it.
A brief review:
In one of the most turbulent and mania era in history, how does individuals pursue love, happiness, dream, while how to survive and protect yourself from the political movements.
This is the most gripping and core illustration part of this TV series.
Which role would you be , if you were in the Cultural Revolution?
Ji Cheng (季诚), just like his name HONEST, is totally a bookish fool.
He is naive, persistent and simple in love. He dare not to challenge or change the status in quo.
Shu Man(舒曼) and he are alumni and friends, their relations are the perfect type of Platonic love.
So when Shu Man chooses Geng Zhi to be her husband, he can't get away from this complex.
Similar like him, Shu Man is quiet, peaceful, passionate inside the heart, but rarely reveal it outside. Conservative and restrained (保守矜持).
Their uniform education background, coming from similar rich and educated families, both have strong pursue to research into medical studies. The two people are so homogeneous that their thinking, lifestyle, even word usage look eerily similar.
When Ji Cheng shouted at Geng Zhi, he called him rude and vulgar (粗鄙), the same word used by Geng's wife Shu Man.
"We are too similar," says Shu, when in a freezing night she was staying in the same room at a strange village. "If we were married, we would respect each other like guests, we may never quarrel or fight, but we will never experience such intense emotions [like Geng Zhi and me did]".
Geng Zhi(耿直), like the word, HONEST & FRANK. A promising PLA battalion commander from the Korean war, he is a model soldier who devoted his life to war, and he would be promoted to be a general one day just as he continues.
As a passionate guy, he ignites his own passion after seeing Shu Man, and is determined to get married with her, in spite of enormous challenges.
"He incites you to sing and dance, he drives you to burn yourself up ", as Shu commented.
He is also a model husband, considerate, understanding, taking all efforts to protect his wife, and would come forward to kill the intruders.
When the Red Guard official tried several times to harass his wife, he threatened and fought with that gangster.
People like Ji Cheng and Shu Man can't survive the political movement, as it happened in thousands of cases during the Cultural Revolution. It's really smart for the director to separate them rather than seeing them commit suicide.
One line to summarize the couple Geng and Shu 's surviving the turbulent era, "You need a capacious mind to do great things" (做大事,大情怀). Geng understands the games of politics in the 1960s-1970s, as a PLA official, so he strained himself to protect the poor family from outside crackdown .
However, their marriage almost bust up in the peaceful times after the Cultural Revolution, when they strive to bring up three children, pursue better career but confronting the cruel reality world.
"On the contrary, peaceful era wears away your passion and mind"(和平时代,磨没了情怀). Geng ended up working for 5 years at a logistics department to distribute eggs and fish for health organization staff.
For a whole life's time, you grow up, find your partner, get married, pursue your career, get pregnant, child is born, bring up your child, their education and career……This is the exact description of the golden wedding couple.
All in all, a great program that definitely worth your time and effort. It drives you to think about your parents, grandparents' generation, their fate, marriage and how they survived the country's last fifty or sixty years.
Great job! Cheers!
2. 社团版杜拉拉升职记
看这部之前,很推崇胡军的另一部作品《岁月》——一个社团版的杜拉拉升职记。鞭辟入里,将社团体系运作逻辑暴露无遗。无所谓好人坏人,你只是系统的一分子。
电视剧版的《岁月》经过多次的删减审核才得以播出,成了宣扬当今官僚体系的杜拉拉升职记,而阅读原著《沧浪之水》则更让人心底透凉……
一个大学刚毕业的研究生分配到卫生局,血气方刚、心直口快得罪曾经非常看重自己的厅领导,进而被下调到边缘部门和其他地方。理性同现实碰撞。感情、婚姻、人情世故、现实窘迫、住房拥挤、工作调动、孩子出生、升学……
一个个现实生活的痛楚折磨,在社团的体系运作里,对一个理想主义者来说,就是痛苦的深渊:婚姻的枯燥乏味已经次要,吝啬、精明、人情练达的妻子步步逼迫他低下头。在重重挫折后,他终于清醒了,选择了妥协,去奉承领导,去排挤他人,几年之后,他很快提拔为科长、处长,并最后接了厅长的班……
3 ) 比第一部好看很多很多 舒曼 很喜欢这个演员
这片子让我爸我妈差点没打起来
我爸爸看到舒曼遭到方队长威胁的时候 气的差点没把杯子摔了~
而我妈则完全理解不了文革那个阶段我爸他们所遭受的迫害
我爸气的快发疯了
我爸因为政审问题毁了他的学业和就业 委屈的不得了 快发疯了
我妈则根正苗红 一切顺利
两个人 在文革那一阶段绝对是完全对立的两拨人
看了这片子 两人真是快打起来了!
好片子 有人说舒曼演的不好 我觉得恰好相反 她演的太好太好了! 一流的演员!
4 ) 广告电视剧
剧情虽然还好,但是后几期的广告实在是太多了,把它在我心中种下的美好印象全毁了,就算剧情再好,就算演技再好,都让这冗长的广告给毁了。
特别是:金龙鱼+一比一比一,还没看完,已经重复了6遍了!
还有:新飞冰箱、蒙牛孕妇奶粉……广告词都念了好几遍
5 ) 如果可以找到像耿直这样的男人过一辈子值了
我最近一直在追着看,一集都落下,真的很好的,那个年代真的开始慢慢喜欢那个年代,比较干净,追求的都很简单,看着心里甜甜的,让人羡慕起那个年代了纯纯的爱情,一辈子相守,比现在的非常勿扰来的真实,有一个像耿直一辈子都在哄着你老公多么幸福啊
6 ) 能不能别再糟蹋中国知识分子的形象?
一部还算不错的电视剧,看到第六第七集就无法往下看了。我不明白编剧是出于什么目的,不知道是不是思维惯式,还是迎合观众,要将南方来的知识分子(女主的姐姐和姐夫)描绘成这样的形象,却无限放大男主角没知识却高大全的形象。
说了这么多年的重视科学重视知识,可是为什么我们的电视里还是要放着这样轻蔑得表达对知识分子感想的电视剧,大家往往还乐此不比,觉得知识分子的形象就该是那样的。
最让人想不通的是,影片中男主第三次换家(一位局级干部,换了这么多次房子,房间这么大,这个我们暂且不去说它。)时说,“人家老季也分了大房子?”“是啊,好歹别人也是个局级干部。”看来,这位极为不想当官的老季医生要不是托得自己是位局级干部,估计作为知识分子的他也赶不上那趟福利分房。看来编剧希望将有知识的人就和磨叽划上等号,希望将没知识但“大气”的干部就划为应该和崇尚的目标。其实这样刻画的国内电视剧作品不算少数了,就不一一举例了。类似题材的电视剧往往将知识分子尤其是南方知识分子刻画成“小气磨叽的小资产阶级”成了惯例。但是问题就是都这么多年了,我们的编剧们能不能有所改变呢?有所突破呢?电视媒体的传播不是应该传送主旋律吗?为什么我们尊重知识分子的主旋律的电视剧却很少在我们的荧屏中看见呢?
是因为我们的知识分子们的故事们不够精彩吗?我想不是的,比如医届的裘法祖先生的德国生活(夫人是德国人,相濡以沫一生),国学届的季老先生德国生活也尤其精彩。为什么我们的荧屏上没有见不到苏步青先生的故事,李国豪先生的故事,童第周先生的故事。。。这么多知识界文化界名人的故事,这么多的资源,却没有编剧愿意去改编呢?
反复得使用着老题材,反复得改拍已经拍过的作品,反复使用着已经用得烂得让人乏味的桥段和理念,为什么却没有编剧愿意有些突破呢?
全剧都靠耿直撑着,好男人,周韵实在不如蒋,植入广告太多了!
冲姜文断断续续在电视上看了点 胡军的桃花阵容真强大 王艳 张延 胡可 一个比一个讨人喜欢。。。
也太好看了吧,耿直有你在,神马叶问好男人都是浮云啊啊啊啊
感动。哭。
看着看着就烦了,可能自己的生活这样子才会觉得有滋有味吧。广告太多太明显但是过程中还是有意思的,尤其刚结婚的十几年
三星半。我更喜欢石菲菲那对
前半部分更纯更真切,后面孩子多了,太乱。
17 1973剧本很一般,最痛恨的是那生硬的广告植入
后面就不好看了
今晚大结局啊
不上瘾但很有意思的电视剧
我居然看了一上午这个= = 丫的,为什么每次看这个的时候看到耿直跟季城斗嘴我都觉得他俩很有爱咧?啧啧....腐烂了!(¯﹃¯)
看了一集差点乐死
这个比张国立那个好多了,张国立和蒋雯丽,永远那副要死不活的模样,看了就转台,讨厌!
老胡军演的太好了,到最后全然是个老头了,我都忘了那个推门的大猛A了,出色!
胡军这大梁挑的真好啊,要哪儿有哪儿,虽然都是村干部的长相他比国立桑有戏太多了,张国立跟蒋雯丽都成扑克牌脸了,这片子最后毁于霸王式植入广告了,闻所未闻简直了,到最后看他们拿起来一个有商标的物体我就害怕
其实很可乐。。。故事也有点意思。。。只是这种戏还植入广告让我有点无语,然后周韵的演技还是…额,不自然。。。虽然笑起来我觉得还挺舒服。
很好看 周韵美的很
真呀吗真好看~~
你们喷我吧..可我真的很喜欢看这个掩面><